Okay, so I’m looking to spoil my cat, Mittens, rotten! But I’m overwhelmed by all the cat toy options out there. She’s about 3 years old, pretty active, and gets bored easily. She likes to chase things, but also enjoys napping and snuggling. She has a scratching post already. What are the absolute best toys to keep a cat like Mittens entertained, physically and mentally stimulated, and happy, considering safety, durability, and lasting appeal? I’d like specific recommendations, not just categories (like "feather wands"), and maybe even reasons why a particular toy is so great. Also, are there any toys that are generally considered a waste of money, or even dangerous, that I should avoid?

Answer

The "best" toys for cats are subjective and depend on the individual cat’s personality, age, play style, and preferences. However, some categories and specific examples are consistently popular and provide enrichment for most cats:

1. Interactive Toys:

• Wand Toys/Fishing Pole Toys: These toys mimic the movement of prey and encourage chasing, pouncing, and jumping. Look for wands with durable rods and a variety of attachments like feathers, ribbons, soft toys, or crinkle material. Examples: Da Bird, Neko Flies, Go Cat Teaser Wand.
• Laser Pointers: Many cats enjoy chasing the elusive red dot. Use with caution and avoid shining the laser in the cat’s eyes. It’s a good idea to occasionally end the play session by directing the laser onto a physical toy the cat can "catch" to prevent frustration.
• Puzzle Toys: These toys challenge cats mentally and physically by requiring them to figure out how to access treats or food. Options range from simple treat balls to more complex puzzles with levers, sliders, and compartments. Examples: Trixie Mad Scientist, Nina Ottosson puzzle toys.
• Automatic/Motion-Activated Toys: These toys provide entertainment when you’re not available to play. They can feature rotating lasers, fluttering butterflies, or unpredictable movements. Be sure the toy is safe and can’t be easily broken or swallowed. Examples: SmartyKat Hot Pursuit, Hexbug Mouse.
• Cat Trees/Climbing Structures: While not strictly a toy, cat trees provide an outlet for climbing, scratching, and perching, which are all essential feline behaviors. Choose a sturdy tree with multiple levels, scratching posts, and hiding spots.

2. Solo Play Toys:

• Small Plush Toys: These toys can be batted, carried, and "killed." Look for durable toys without small parts that could be swallowed. Many cats like catnip-filled toys. Examples: Kong Kickeroo, Yeowww! Catnip Toys.
• Crinkle Balls/Mylar Balls: The crinkling sound of these lightweight balls is irresistible to many cats. They are easy to bat around and chase.
• Catnip Toys: Catnip is a natural herb that elicits a euphoric response in many cats. Catnip toys can be a great way to encourage play and relaxation. Experiment with different forms of catnip (dried, spray, infused) to see what your cat prefers.
• Spring Toys: These toys bounce unpredictably and provide a good workout for chasing and pouncing.
• Ping Pong Balls/Golf Balls: Simple, lightweight balls that cats can easily bat around.

3. Scratching Toys:

• Scratching Posts: Essential for maintaining claw health and preventing furniture damage. Offer a variety of scratching posts, including vertical posts, horizontal pads, and angled ramps. Materials like sisal, cardboard, and carpet are all popular.
• Scratching Pads: Cardboard scratching pads are a popular and inexpensive option. They come in various shapes and sizes and can be placed on the floor or hung on a wall.

4. Safety Considerations:

• Size: Toys should be large enough that your cat cannot swallow them.
• Materials: Avoid toys with small parts that could be chewed off and ingested, such as buttons, ribbons, or plastic eyes.
• Durability: Choose toys made from durable materials that can withstand rough play.
• Supervision: Always supervise your cat when they are playing with new toys, especially those that are small or have parts that could be easily detached.
• Rotation: Rotate your cat’s toys regularly to keep them interested and engaged. Put away some toys and bring them out again later to make them feel new.
• Hygiene: Clean your cat’s toys regularly to remove dirt and bacteria.

Individual Cat Preferences:

• Observe Your Cat: Pay attention to what types of toys your cat seems most interested in. Do they prefer toys that move quickly, toys that make noise, or toys that they can carry around?
• Experiment: Try a variety of different toys to see what your cat likes best.
• Consider Their Age: Kittens may prefer smaller, lighter toys, while older cats may prefer toys that are easier to catch and manipulate.
• Think About Their Hunting Style: Some cats are natural hunters who enjoy chasing and pouncing, while others are more interested in exploring and investigating. Choose toys that match your cat’s hunting style.

By considering these categories, safety guidelines, and your individual cat’s preferences, you can create a stimulating and enjoyable play environment for your feline companion.