Is cracking your knuckles bad for you? Specifically, I’ve heard conflicting information about whether it causes arthritis, reduces grip strength, or has any long-term negative effects on joint health. I’m curious about the science behind what causes the cracking sound, and whether there’s a difference in the effects depending on how often someone cracks their knuckles, or the force they use. Are there any reliable studies that have looked into this extensively, or is it mostly anecdotal evidence?
Answer
Whether cracking your knuckles is bad for you is a subject of debate, but the prevailing scientific evidence suggests it’s generally harmless.
What Causes the Cracking Sound?
For many years, the prevailing theory was that the popping sound was caused by the bursting of nitrogen bubbles in the synovial fluid, which lubricates the joints. This theory was largely supported by a 1971 study.
However, a more recent study in 2015, utilizing MRI video, suggested a different mechanism. This study proposed that the sound is created by the sudden formation of a gas-filled cavity within the joint. This "tribonucleation" process occurs as the joint surfaces separate, reducing pressure and causing dissolved gases to rapidly come out of solution and form a bubble. The sound is produced when this cavity forms.
Potential Risks and Lack Thereof:
-
Arthritis: The most common concern is whether knuckle cracking leads to arthritis, specifically osteoarthritis. Numerous studies have investigated this, and the consensus is that there’s no demonstrable link. A very famous study, conducted by Donald Unger, who cracked the knuckles of his left hand every day for over 60 years but never cracked the knuckles of his right hand, found no increase in arthritis in either hand. He ultimately won an Ig Nobel Prize for his work.
-
Grip Strength: Some studies have suggested a possible, albeit weak, correlation between habitual knuckle cracking and reduced grip strength. However, these studies are often limited by small sample sizes and confounding factors. More robust research is needed to determine if there is a genuine causal relationship.
-
Hand Swelling and Lower Dexterity: A few studies have hinted at a potential association between knuckle cracking and hand swelling or decreased hand dexterity. However, like the grip strength studies, these findings are not consistently replicated and may be influenced by other underlying conditions.
- Soft Tissue Injury: While rare, it’s theoretically possible to injure the ligaments or tendons around the knuckles through forceful or improper cracking. However, this is generally considered to be an uncommon occurrence.
When to See a Doctor:
If knuckle cracking is accompanied by pain, swelling, or limited range of motion, it’s important to consult a doctor or physical therapist to rule out any underlying joint problems or injuries.
Conclusion:
Based on current evidence, habitual knuckle cracking is not likely to cause arthritis or other serious health problems for most people. However, if you experience any pain or discomfort associated with cracking your knuckles, seek medical advice. While generally considered harmless, the social implications of the habit can be annoying to others.