Subscribe to Breaking Chains Prayers


Is zinc oxide marketed in sunscreens actually reef safe? I’ve seen conflicting information online, with some sources claiming it’s a safe alternative to chemical UV filters like oxybenzone and octinoxate, while others suggest that even non-nano zinc oxide particles can still negatively impact coral reefs. Specifically, I’m interested in understanding: What’s the scientific evidence regarding the effects of different sizes and coatings of zinc oxide particles on coral larvae, adult corals, and other reef organisms? Are there specific formulations of zinc oxide sunscreens that are demonstrably safer for reefs than others, perhaps due to particle size, coating, or other additives? And, considering the practical application of sunscreen, how does the concentration of zinc oxide released into the water during swimming affect the reef ecosystem, taking into account factors like water currents and dilution? Finally, are there independent certifications or labeling standards that can help consumers reliably identify truly reef-safe zinc oxide sunscreens?

Answer

Whether zinc oxide is truly "reef safe" is a complex question with no simple yes or no answer. The broad scientific consensus leans towards uncoated, non-nano zinc oxide being a better option than many chemical sunscreen ingredients, but even it can pose some environmental risks under certain conditions. Here’s a breakdown:

What makes zinc oxide a potentially better choice?

  • Mineral-based: Zinc oxide is a mineral sunscreen active ingredient, meaning it physically blocks UV rays rather than absorbing them like chemical sunscreen ingredients (oxybenzone, octinoxate, octocrylene, homosalate, avobenzone). The latter have been shown to cause coral bleaching and endocrine disruption in marine life.

  • Broad spectrum protection: Zinc oxide effectively blocks both UVA and UVB rays.

Factors impacting reef safety and concerns about Zinc Oxide:

  • Particle Size: Nano vs. Non-Nano:

    • Nano-sized zinc oxide (particles smaller than 100 nanometers) are used to make sunscreens more transparent and easier to apply. However, nano-particles are more readily ingested by marine organisms. Studies have suggested nano-particles can:

      • Cause oxidative stress and DNA damage in marine organisms.
      • Interfere with the feeding behavior of coral.
      • Accumulate in the food chain.
      • Disrupt the symbiotic relationship between coral and algae.
    • Non-nano zinc oxide (particles larger than 100 nanometers) are less likely to be ingested and are generally considered safer. These sunscreens tend to leave a white cast on the skin. Look for sunscreens that explicitly state "non-nano" zinc oxide.

  • Coating:

    • Zinc oxide particles are often coated with materials like silica, dimethicone, or alumina to improve their dispersion, stability, and cosmetic feel.

    • The impact of these coatings on the environment is still under investigation. Some coatings may release potentially harmful substances as they degrade. Some studies suggest these coatings affect the toxicity of Zinc Oxide particles.

  • Concentration: The amount of zinc oxide released into the water is a key factor. High concentrations, even of non-nano zinc oxide, can be harmful. Areas with high tourist activity and frequent sunscreen use are at greater risk.

  • Other Ingredients: A sunscreen’s reef safety is not solely determined by the presence of zinc oxide. Many sunscreens contain other ingredients, such as preservatives, emulsifiers, and fragrances, that can also harm marine life. Ingredients like parabens, phthalates, and synthetic fragrances should be avoided.

  • Water Chemistry: Seawater pH and the presence of other pollutants can influence the behavior and toxicity of zinc oxide particles. For example, acidic conditions can increase the dissolution of zinc oxide, releasing zinc ions that are toxic to some marine organisms.

  • Sediment Accumulation: Zinc oxide particles can settle on the seabed, potentially affecting benthic organisms (those living on the bottom).

  • Specific Marine Organisms: The sensitivity to zinc oxide varies among different marine species. Some organisms are more susceptible than others.

What can you do to minimize your impact?

  • Choose non-nano, uncoated zinc oxide sunscreens: Look for products explicitly labeled as "non-nano" zinc oxide. Sunscreen brands are now becoming more transparent about ingredients and particle sizes.

  • Read the ingredient list carefully: Avoid sunscreens with oxybenzone, octinoxate, octocrylene, homosalate, avobenzone, parabens, phthalates, and synthetic fragrances.

  • Consider alternative sun protection: Wear protective clothing (rash guards, hats, sunglasses), and seek shade during peak sun hours.

  • Apply sunscreen responsibly: Apply sunscreen 15-20 minutes before sun exposure and reapply frequently, especially after swimming or sweating. Apply indoors or away from the beach to prevent direct release into the water.

  • Use sunscreen only when necessary: If you’re not swimming or participating in water activities, wearing protective clothing might be sufficient.

  • Support reef-safe initiatives: Choose tour operators and businesses that are committed to protecting coral reefs. Educate yourself and others about reef-safe practices.